Copyediting vs line editing: Which service does your manuscript need?

The choice between copyediting vs line editing is pivotal for writers finalising their manuscripts. Each editing service brings unique strengths, addressing distinct aspects of your manuscript’s improvement. But which one does your manuscript need?

To make an informed decision, it is crucial to understand the fundamental differences between these two editing approaches. Copyediting focuses on grammar, punctuation, spelling and consistency. This ensures your text is error-free and adheres to established style guidelines.

On the other hand, line editing digs deeper, enhancing your manuscript’s readability, flow and overall style. This article will provide a clear and concise exploration of the distinctions between copyediting vs line editing.

First, it will equip you with the knowledge to discern which editing service aligns with the specific manuscript needs. Secondly, this article will explain professional editors’ role in elevating your book’s quality. By the end of this post, you will have the insights you need to determine which service best fits your manuscript’s unique requirements. Keep reading.

Copyediting vs line editing

What is copyediting?

Copyediting examines your manuscript for grammar, spelling, punctuation and consistency errors. It is the fine-toothed comb that goes through your text to ensure it adheres to established language and style guidelines. This level of editing focuses on the mechanics of your writing, providing that it is free from distracting errors.

When does your manuscript need copyediting?

Copyediting comes into play when your manuscript is well-structured but requires polish and precision. If your narrative already flows smoothly, you must ensure that your manuscript lacks grammatical errors and inconsistencies. Copyediting is the appropriate choice in the copyediting vs line editing dilemma. This editing stage guarantees that your work is free of distracting mistakes. This offers readers clarity and professionalism.

How much should you budget for copyediting?

When determining your budget for copyediting, it is essential to recognise the value of professional expertise. As the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading suggests, hourly copyediting rates typically start from £34.70.

While this might seem like an investment, it reflects the editor’s extensive training and experience. A professional copyeditor not only corrects errors but also understands your text, determining the appropriate level of editorial intervention. They document their editing decisions and suggestions, ensuring every change is intentional and justifiable.

This means that even though the hourly rate might appear higher, you are paying for a depth of expertise. If you encounter a significantly lower estimate for copyediting, it is crucial to consider whether it represents a compromise in editing quality, potentially undermining the integrity of your manuscript. Ultimately, your budget for copyediting should align with your commitment to presenting a polished and professionally edited manuscript to your readers.

What benefits does copyediting come with?

  • Clarity: Copyediting ensures your writing is clear and concise, eliminating ambiguity and confusion.
  • Professionalism: It lends a professional touch to your work, leaving a positive impression on readers.
  • Consistency: It enforces consistent style and formatting throughout your manuscript.
  • Error-free: Most importantly, copyediting guarantees that your manuscript is error-free, enhancing its readability.

What is line editing?

Line editing is a profound and artistic aspect in comparing copyediting vs line editing. It transcends the surface-level corrections and dives deep into the core of your writing. Unlike copyediting, line editing focuses on the essence of your prose.

The creative enhancement elevates your manuscript beyond well-constructed content to a literary masterpiece. Line editors pay attention to your writing style.

This ensures seamless transitions between sentences, maintaining a consistent tone to make your text more captivating. Additionally, they assess pacing, rearranging sentences or paragraphs for a dynamic flow that engages readers.

When does your manuscript need line editing?

Your manuscript should undergo line editing when you seek to elevate it to a higher literary level. If you have already ensured that it is free from grammatical errors and consistency issues but aspire to craft a narrative on a stylistic and artistic level. In that case, line editing is the answer in the copyediting vs line editing debate.

It is the stage where your writing transitions from good to outstanding. Line editing is particularly beneficial if you want to refine sentence structures, select the perfect words, enhance the rhythm of your prose and create a memorable reading experience.

How much should you budget for line editing?

When budgeting for line editing, it is crucial to appreciate the value that professional expertise brings to your manuscript. The current hourly rates, suggested by the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading, typically start from £39.90.

While this might seem like an investment, it reflects the editor’s extensive training and experience, allowing them to justify their rates with a depth of knowledge. A professional line editor does not merely correct sentences and paragraphs; they first immerse themselves in your entire text to ensure consistency of tone, voice and style throughout the manuscript.

This holistic approach, though unseen, significantly contributes to the quality of your writing. Consequently, if you encounter a substantially lower estimate for line editing, it is essential to consider whether it might compromise the quality of editing your manuscript deserves in the copyediting vs line editing decision.

What benefits does line editing come with?

  • Improved readability: Line editing improves the overall readability of your manuscript, making it more engaging for your audience.
  • Enhanced style: It refines your unique writing style, giving it a distinct and memorable voice.
  • Creative enhancement: Line editors help you find the perfect words, sentence structure and pacing to convey your ideas effectively.
  • Flow and consistency: Line editing ensures that your manuscript flows seamlessly from start to finish.

Copyediting vs line editing: Choosing the right service for your manuscript

So, the critical question remains: which one does your manuscript need? The answer largely depends on your work’s current state and overarching goals. Here is a straightforward guideline to help you decide:

  • Choose copyediting if your manuscript is generally well-written but needs a final check for errors and consistency. Copyediting provides that finishing touch that ensures your work is polished and error-free.
  • Choose line editing if your manuscript requires deeper refinement. If you are seeking to elevate the artistry of your writing and address issues related to sentence structure, pacing and overall style, line editing is the way to go.

It is also important to note that both services have their place in publishing. It is not uncommon for you to benefit from both copyediting and line editing sequentially. Your manuscript can first undergo copyediting to ensure it is error-free, followed by line editing to refine its style and narrative quality.

Why should you hire a professional editor for copyediting vs line editing?

When faced with the choice between copyediting vs line editing, hiring a professional editor becomes imperative for several compelling reasons. First and foremost, a professional editor brings a wealth of expertise and a trained eye to your manuscript. They possess an in-depth understanding of the nuances of both editing processes and can identify issues you might have overlooked.

Moreover, a professional editor offers an objective perspective on your work. They approach your manuscript as a reader would, helping you see it from an outsider’s viewpoint. This objectivity is invaluable in addressing potential shortcomings or areas that require improvement.

Working with a professional editor also saves you time and effort. Editing can be a labour-intensive process, and having a skilled editor streamlines this task, allowing you to focus on your writing and storytelling.

Furthermore, editors customise their approach to your specific needs. Whether you require copyediting to ensure error-free content or line editing to elevate your writing’s artistry, a professional editor tailors their services accordingly.

Final thoughts

In the world of copyediting vs line editing, the choice ultimately boils down to your manuscript’s current state and goals. If your work is well-structured but needs that final polish, copyediting is your go-to for perfect correctness.

On the other hand, if you aspire to elevate your writing to an art form, then line editing is the path to take. Remember, both have their place in perfecting your manuscript. Moreover, enlisting the services of a professional editor is paramount, as their expertise and objectivity elevate your work beyond the ordinary.

By harnessing the power of these book editors, you can confidently navigate the publishing competition, knowing that your story will reach its audience in its most polished and impactful form. Contact me for a free sample edit (and remember to use my early bird discount) to determine if your manuscript may benefit from developmental editing. If you want to hear more from me, including self-editing and writing tips, follow me on MastodonTwitterFacebook and LinkedIn or join my newsletter.

Photo of author


I am an editor, indexer and a lifelong lover of literature with a PhD in literary history. I am an Intermediate Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading, a student member of the Society of Indexers and a vetted partner of the Alliance of Independent Authors.