How to evaluate a sample line edit?

Evaluating a sample line edit involves assessing an editor’s style, feedback format and feedback quality. This evaluation helps determine whether the editor’s approach aligns with your writing goals and can enhance your manuscript. By scrutinising the editor’s approach, clarity of feedback and the quality of suggested changes, you can make an informed decision about collaborating with an editor who resonates with your creative vision. As we dive into this topic, it is important to note that not only the sample edit but also the editor’s portfolio provides a window into their skills, style and experience. By examining their portfolio alongside a sample line edit, you can comprehensively understand the editor’s capabilities and approach.

This combined insight empowers you to make informed choices, ensuring that the selected editor aligns perfectly with the project’s requirements and your vision. Read on to learn more about the key considerations that should guide your assessment of a sample line edit and what lies beyond a line editor’s portfolio.

What is a sample line edit?

A sample line edit is a small portion of your writing that an editor works on to demonstrate their editing skills and approach. It showcases the editor’s style and how they would edit your entire manuscript. Most editors will provide a sample edit for free to make sure their contribution aligns with your expectations. Are you considering hiring a professional editor for your work? Then, a sample line edit is a must-have, as it allows you to assess the editor’s suitability and the potential impact of their improvements.

What is the purpose of a sample line edit?

Think of a sample line edit as a writing health check, making sure your choices, voice, and style are conveyed in the best possible way for your intended reader. A sample line edit is important in the following ways:

  • It showcases how an editor improves clarity, coherence and readability in a piece of writing.
  • It offers a glimpse into the editor’s unique style, giving you an idea of how your manuscripts can be enhanced.
  • Authors can use the sample edit to evaluate the editor’s suitability for their project before committing to a full edit.
  • It highlights the editor’s attention to detail and ability to identify and rectify issues within the text.
  • It demonstrates how the editor respects and enhances the author’s voice while refining the writing.
  • It illustrates how the editor’s changes can elevate the overall reading experience for the intended audience.

How do you evaluate a sample line edit?

Editing is a crucial step in the journey of a manuscript from a raw creation to a polished publication. In the competitive publishing world, you need to present your work in its best possible form. That is where a sample line edit comes into play. It provides insights into how a professional editor can refine and enhance your writing. Therefore, the following are the check factors during this process.

Editing style and approach

Every editor has a unique style and approach that they bring to their work. A sample line edit provides a glimpse into the editor’s methods. It showcases how they meticulously scrutinise each sentence, considering grammar, syntax and structure factors. By assessing the changes, you can discover if their style aligns with your expectations.

Feedback format

The feedback format of a sample line edit reveals how the editor communicates their suggestions and improvements. Whether through comments, recommendations or track changes, this format helps you understand how effectively they convey their insights. A well-structured feedback format ensures you can quickly grasp the areas needing attention and the rationale behind the changes.

Feedback quality

The quality of feedback in a sample line edit is of paramount importance. It reflects the depth of the editor’s analysis and ability to identify both glaring and nuanced issues. The sample edit demonstrates whether the editor’s feedback enhances your writing, preserves your voice, and aligns with your goals.

Editing scope

Suppose you have established a specific editing level in advance, such as opting for comprehensive developmental editing or focusing solely on a thorough copyedit. In that case, assessing if the editor adhered to this agreed scope is crucial. Was your chosen editing framework respected? Additionally, if the editing process extended beyond the anticipated level (perhaps due to prior inadequate editing), did the editor provide clear explanations for these adjustments?

Clarity and coherence

Assess whether the sample line edit enhances the clarity and coherence of your writing. Are sentences more concise? Do paragraphs flow seamlessly? Improved clarity ensures concise communication of ideas, removing unnecessary complexities. Coherence provides coherent transitions between sentences and paragraphs, enhancing the logical flow of the narrative.

Sensitivity and respect

Gauge how the editor handles sensitive content, ensuring accurate conveyance while respecting the subject. The editor must handle delicate topics carefully, providing precise representation and considerate communication.

What else should you consider when hiring a line editor?

A sample edit is not the only consideration when hiring a line editor. For instance, a line editing portfolio serves as a glimpse into an editor’s past work and expertise. However, crucial aspects are often overlooked and not included in the portfolio. They include the following.


When assessing a line editor, it is essential to go beyond their portfolio and consider practical aspects that can significantly impact the editing process. Look for effective communication and timely responses, which contribute to smooth collaboration. Additionally, inquire about their adaptability to your project’s unique needs and whether they can tailor their editing style accordingly. Examine whether the editor respected the scope of editing you discussed beforehand and whether any deviations were explained. These practicalities go beyond the portfolio sample line edit and are crucial for a successful collaboration.

Professional affiliations

Find out if the editor is a member of any professional organisations for editors. These associations ensure their members receive ongoing training and adhere to a code of practice. The commitment set forth by these organisations makes their members qualified and reliable editors. Here is a list of the professional editing associations around the world:


While a line editing portfolio provides valuable insights into an editor’s previous work, diving into other spheres of their qualifications is equally essential, particularly language. Look for editors with a strong command of vocabulary and grammar, demonstrated through relevant certifications or educational background. Assess whether they have experience in your specific genre or niche, as this familiarity can enhance the accuracy and effectiveness of their edits. Prioritise editors who are well-versed in industry-standard style guides, ensuring consistency and professionalism in your manuscript. Feel free to ask for references or testimonials from authors they have worked with to understand their effectiveness and collaborative approach. Qualifications beyond the portfolio and sample edit, play a vital role in ensuring that your editing process is in capable and knowledgeable hands.

Final thoughts

Mastering evaluating a sample line edit equips you with a valuable tool to elevate your writing journey. By examining the editing style and approach in a sample line edit, its clarity, coherence, editing scope and feedback quality, you are empowered to make informed decisions about your manuscript. A sample line edit is a window into the editor’s approach and your manuscript’s potential transformation. This knowledge empowers you to make informed decisions and collaborate effectively with expert editors, ensuring their literary creations achieve excellence. Contact me for a free sample edit (and remember to use my early bird discount) to determine if your manuscript may benefit from developmental editing. If you want to hear more from me, including self-editing and writing tips, follow me on Mastodon, Twitter, Facebook and LinkedIn or join my newsletter.

Photo of author


I am an editor, indexer and a lifelong lover of literature with a PhD in literary history. I am an Intermediate Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading, a student member of the Society of Indexers and a vetted partner of the Alliance of Independent Authors.